An Oklahoma dairy farmer disappears with a mysterious stranger.

Lenny Dirickson


Gender: Male
DOB: 7/25/58
Height: 5’10”
Weight: 200 lbs.
Eyes: Brown
Hair: Gray
Defining Characteristics: Handlebar mustache at the time of his disappearance
Remarks: Last seen 3/14/98


Lenny left with a stranger

March 14, 1998, began as a typical morning at Leonard Dirickson’s dairy farm near Cheyenne, Oklahoma.   Leonard and his 19 year old son, Jared, sat down to eat breakfast before a long day of chores.

Then, at 9 AM, a visitor arrived unannounced in a white pickup truck. Leonard spent several minutes talking to the driver of the truck.   They did not appear to know each other, but their conversation seemed friendly.

When Leonard returned, he told Jared that the man wanted to look at one of his stud horses. According to Jared, his father found nothing unusual about the stranger:

“So he told me that he was gonna go with him.   He said to stay here and… get some feed and go feed the cows, and he’d be back that afternoon.”  

Suspect wanted for questioning

Jared Dirickson is still waiting for his father to come home.   Nobody has any idea what happened to him.   Police have found no signs of a struggle, no evidence of foul play, and no body. Their only clue is the mysterious man who came to Leonard’s house.

Apparently, Leonard did not simply vanish immediately after leaving his home.   Two hours later, a waitress claimed to have seen Leonard eating breakfast with another man at a local coffee shop.

Clif Gann was an Inspector for the Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation:

“They were sitting there in the restaurant. And the unknown man that we’re trying to identify was doing most of the talking, and Leonard was just drinking coffee and listening to the… man talk.”   

Did the man know where Lenny lived?

The man at the diner matched the description of the man who picked Leonard up at his home. According to the waitress, there was nothing suspicious about the man’s behavior.

Police checked the barn where Leonard kept his stud horse.   But Leonard never went there that day.   An exhaustive investigation that followed turned up no information on Leonard’s whereabouts.

Then six months after he vanished, a man phoned police saying that Leonard Dirickson was in a bar in Amarillo, Texas. The man described Leonard in detail but told police he couldn’t reveal his name.

By the time local police arrived at the bar, both the caller and the man he claimed was Leonard Dirickson were gone.

Lenny was spotted at a bar

The following day, the Roger Mills County Sheriff’s Department interviewed the bartender.   She remembered the caller being at the bar and corroborated his story.

Joe Hay was the Sheriff of Roger Mills County:

“We had no reason to disbelieve it.   It would almost stretch the imagination that a guy would dance around in a bar screaming and hollering, ‘It’s Leonard, it’s Leonard,’ and it not be Leonard.   I believe he was in the bar in Amarillo.”

Before his disappearance, Leonard had gone through a painful divorce and was having financial difficulties.  Could he have just decided to walk away from it all? Jared Dirickson doesn’t think so:

“Me and my dad, we was together every day.   Every morning, we’d go work, do the chores, and I’d go to school.   I don’t think he would’ve ever left me and not ever come back to see me or nothing, ’cause…we was close, and I don’t think he’d have ever done that to me.”

If Leonard would not have left his son behind, the focus then switches back to the mysterious man.   How did the stranger know where Leonard lived? And why was he asking about a horse that Leonard had not advertised for sale?    Without a motive, the search for Leonard Dirickson will continue to be hampered.

Watch this case now on Amazon Prime in season eleven with Robert Stack and in season two with Dennis Farina. Also available on YouTube with Dennis FarinaVarious seasons available now on Hulu.



  1. TDS

    I care, John 🙂 I have visited the unsolved website for years, and I always check to see if there are any updates on Lenny, always hoping there will be something. I didn’t know him or anything like that, but his disappearance is just so puzzling, and I never forgot about his story. I have difficulty believing the part of the story about him being in Texas, because I can’t imagine a father not at least contacting his son to let him know that he is okay. It’s a very sad story, and I hope one day there will be a resolution.


  2. John

    Guess nobody cares about lenny because I see no comments.