Eleven murders of prostitutes working out of truck stops have been linked to an Ohio serial killer.
On April 19th, 1990, the half-nude body of a woman was discovered behind a truck stop on Interstate 70 in Licking County, Ohio. She had been beaten to death, and all of her jewelry and several pieces of her clothing were missing. Despite a full investigation by local authorities, the victim was never identified.
Four years earlier, the body of 23-year-old Shirley Dean Taylor had been found behind a traffic barrier 100 miles to the north. A known prostitute, Shirley had also been beaten to death. In addition, all of Shirley’s jewelry and several pieces of clothing had been removed from her body.
Two seemingly isolated crimes were committed four years and a hundred miles apart. Murder cases often are often solved when a pattern emerges, and in these highway killings, the pattern was just waiting to be discovered. But amazingly, the man who made the connection wasn’t actually looking for it. Investigative Reporter Michael Berens was starting to do research for a newspaper article about serial killers for the Columbia Dispatch:
Berens began to cross reference unsolved murder cases in Ohio. To his surprise, a distinct pattern began to emerge almost immediately. Eight women, in eight different counties, had been beaten or strangled to death. Each was found alongside a major interstate, each was a known or suspected prostitute, and each was known to have worked at truck stops.
Upon further investigation, Berens says he discovered a flourishing sex-for-sale industry at truck stops throughout the state:
On February 8th, 1987, twenty-seven year old Anna Marie Patterson became the sixth known victim in Ohio. In reviewing the investigation of her murder, Berens uncovered several possible clues to the killer’s identity.
Anna Marie had been working at a truck stop in Austintown, just south of Cleveland. Witnesses said her last call was from a driver of a black or dark blue Peterbilt truck. The man used the C.B. handle “Doctor No.” Twenty-five days later, Anna Marie’s body was found alongside interstate 71, north of Cincinnati. Warren County Sheriff James Collins was one of the officers assigned to the case:
Anna Marie’s head had been bashed in and she was brutally beaten. An autopsy revealed that she had been killed within 48 hours of her disappearance. Disturbingly, the condition of her body clearly indicated that the killer had kept it refrigerated for nearly a month. Michael Berens:
According to Berens, the killing spree began nine years earlier with the murder of a woman who has never been identified. Since then, the bodies of seven other victims have been found along interstates in different counties. Each woman had been viciously beaten or strangled to death, and each had jewelry and clothing removed from her body.
A newspaper in Columbus, Ohio, ran Michael Berens’ shocking story, with its compelling evidence that explained how the murders of the eight women were the work of one killer. Ten days later, the Ohio Attorney General and the Buckeye State Sheriff’s Association formed a special task force. Ohio Attorney General Lee Fisher learned that counties within Ohio were not communicating properly:
According to Michael Berens, another alarming clue in this case suggests a disturbing possibility about the killer’s identity:
At least two of the victims were last seen getting into a black or dark blue Peterbilt tractor, possibly pulling a refrigerated trailer. The driver may use the C.B. handles, ‘Dr. No’, ‘Stargazer’, or ‘Dragon’.
UPDATE: The Jane Doe discovered in 1990 has been identified as Patrice Corley. In October 2016, Corley’s family filed a missing person report, which led to her identification. Her murder investigation has been reopened. In February of 2019, forty-nine-year-old truck driver Samuel W. Legg was arrested and charged with the murder of Sharon Lynn Kedzierski who was found dead at a truck stop and had been listed as a Jane Doe for two decades. DNA evidence linked Legg to the murder, along with two others in Ohio and one in Illinois. All of the victims were found near truck stops. Police allege that he is the killer in the other Ohio prostitute murder cases. A judge ruled that Legg was currently not competent to stand trial and will undergo continuous evaluation until he is ruled competent to face charges of murder.