Skip to content
New Case Every Week

The Podcast

New cases every week. Hear from the investigators, the witnesses, and the families hoping to solve a mystery.

61 November 30, 2022

Secret Diary of a Missing Girl

Secret Diary of a Missing Girl

On September 23rd, 1998, 19-year-old University of Wisconsin junior Amber Wilde disappears from her off-campus apartment, never to be seen again. At the time, Amber is 4.5 months pregnant and has a troubled relationship with the baby’s father. Will the discovery of her secret diary be the key to solving her disappearance?

60 September 28, 2022

Murder of an Undercover Cop

Murder of an Undercover Cop

In the summer of 1996, the tight-knit community of Cumberland, Rhode Island, is shocked when beloved police Detective Corporal James “Jimmy” Grimes is found murdered in a downtown Providence parking lot. Surveillance video shows an unidentified man exit Jimmy’s car and soon after Jimmy was found dead, his neck broken, military-style. Who killed Jimmy Grimes?

59 September 21, 2022

Alien Abduction in Indiana

Alien Abduction in Indiana

When a life-long abduction experiencer, going by the alias “Suzie” to protect her privacy, was just fifteen, she began having unexplainable dreams of alien encounters. Decades later, she meets Abduction Researcher and Counselor John Budrys, who has spoken to many people with stories just like hers. For the first time, Suzie is ready to share her experiences.

58 September 14, 2022

Island Justice

Island Justice

When 26-year-old Desiree Gibbon’s brutalized remains are found in the bushes four miles from Montego Bay, Jamaica, her mother is convinced the killer was someone she knew and trusted. But in a small, poor country where the sheer number of homicides overwhelms law enforcement, the Jamaican investigation has turned up few clues. Who killed the young model and what was…

57 September 7, 2022

A Life Cut Short

A Life Cut Short

When police discover 18-year-old Brittany Phillips brutally murdered in her apartment on September 30, 2004, they hope DNA samples collected from the scene will lead them to the man who sexually assaulted and strangled the Tulsa Community College student. Nearly 18 years and hundreds of suspects later, Brittany’s mother has taken to the road in search of the killer.

56 August 31, 2022

The Disappearance of Tabitha Tuders

The Disappearance of Tabitha Tuders

Everyday, 13-year-old Tabitha Tuders leaves her home in East Nashville, Tennessee, and walks a few blocks to catch the school bus. But the morning of April 29, 2003, is different. Somewhere between her home and the bus stop, Tabitha vanishes. Did she run away? Was she abducted by a stranger? Or kidnapped by someone she knew? And why, after 19…

55 August 24, 2022

The Professor’s Execution

The Professor’s Execution

In 2017, popular college professor Matthew Lange is rebuilding a life for himself and his son after a contentious divorce and custody battle. On January 27th, when Matthew is picking his young son up from school, he is ambushed in the parking lot and shot execution style. Who would want Matthew dead?

54 August 17, 2022

Bigfoot: Face to Face

Bigfoot: Face to Face

Paranormal investigator Walter Padilla is traumatized when he comes face to face with a nine-foot creature that he believes to be the infamous Bigfoot. Subsequent investigations at the same location uncover compelling evidence that there is something, or possibly a pack of “somethings,” lurking in the brush in the forest outside of Willis, Texas.

Know a Case Like These?

Bring it to the podcast

Submit a Case