The Podcast
New cases every week. Hear from the investigators, the witnesses, and the families hoping to solve a mystery.
Blood & Oil
In Centerville, Texas, a 911 operator receives a call from a man named Gerald Wilhelm who reports, in a strangely calm voice, that he just woke up from a nap and found his wife, Janice, dead, in a pool of blood, in the same room where he was sleeping. Gerald claims she must have taken her own life by shooting…
Where’s Alicia?
On February 28, 2019, Alicia Griffin leaves her Sacramento apartment to attend a routine doctor's appointment. Two days later, the organized, hyper-detailed Griffin is spotted wondering through a car wash in Tijuana, where she abandons car, purse, and all identification. She has not been seen since.
Three Dead at Blue Ridge Bank
In 2003, an unknown gunman walks into the Blue Ridge Savings Bank in Greer, South Carolina, robs the bank, then forces the lone bank employee and two customers into the break room where he executes all three. For the past seventeen years, David Holtzclaw, the son of the teller, Sylvia, has fought to keep this unsolved case alive.
Demonic Possession
Dr. Richard Gallager is a Harvard and Yale-trained, board-certified psychiatrist who evaluates cases of demonic possession on behalf of the clergy. While he claims cases of true possessions are rare, he also maintains that they are real. Dr. Gallagher shares his experiences in his work, the cases that still stick with him still, and what he believes to be the…
Fatal Fire
Kathy Blentlinger fears she's being stalked by her own sister-in-law, Suzy, who's rumored to be setting fires all over town. When Kathy dies in a house fire after an argument with Suzy, her death is ruled a homicide and her brother and sister are convinced Suzy had something to do with it. No one is arrested and Suzy passes away,…
Two Dead Wives
In February 1999, Robert Kalosky finds his wife, Paula, shot to death in their home after returning from running errands. Her death is ruled a suicide but Paula’s brother, John Carbo fights to have the manner of death ruled a homicide, suspecting that Robert was involved in his sister’s death. Eighteen years later, Robert Kalosky’s second wife, Sandra, is found…
Texts from a Killer?
Paralegal Maria Jimenez-Rodriguez (29) fails to show up for work after dropping off her daughter at daycare. Her co-workers receive texts from Maria, but later question if she actually wrote them. Maria is never seen again. After police question her trainer, Erik Arceneaux, he flees the area and remains a fugitive from the law.
The Shadow Man
The Pracht family has just moved into a rural Nebraska farmhouse when they begin to be harassed and taunted by the ghost of a psychopathic serial killer from the 1890s. How can they rid the house of his spirit?